( BANGKOK STYLE.... )
GRAFFITI IN THE NEWS -
Graffiti - But is it 'Art'?
-
THE DEBATE RAGES....
|
Bangkok Eyes -specifically this MIDNITE HOUR column- has been scolded, warned and even threatened not to continue with our Graffiti Page by those who would see themselves as society's personal guardians. And then there are those who have praised the Graffiti Page, sometimes for artisitc reasons, and sometimes for reasons known only to society's rebellious, and sometimes just because they uncritically like to look at the photos.
But in any case, graffiti being now just on 2,000 years old (see our History Of graffiti ) it is highly unlikely that the practice will cease anytime in the near future, despite what we, or the hundreds of other websites might publish on the subject. And it appears that the two sides, graffiti's praisers, and graffiti's condemners, will likewise never see eye-to-eye on what graffiti is, or is not. The debate rages, as municipalities and campuses and local governments continually increase their efforts at stopping and cleaning up after these 'spraycan menaces'.
.....And then, there's graffiti......
|
The two opposing viewpoints were recently summed up rather succinctly by a remarkably well-balanced article appearing in the Arizona Daily Wildcat's web page
azwildcat online <link>, which in this instance was addressing a spate of college campus graffiti taggings. Parts of their article have been excerpted here:
THE ANTI-GRAFFITI POSITION -
" Defining art and crime -
Officer Frank Romero of the UAPD's crime prevention unit, says the issue of graffiti is over the expression of art versus the mentality of destruction.
"If you've got an item or structure that was created one way, to serve a certain purpose and look a certain way, a building, a bench, a sign or even a tree, if someone alters that item and purposely intended to alter the appearance of that item, then it's graffiti. Whether it says 'Susie loves Johnny' or 'whatever rules', it's all graffiti .
"The graffiti found on campus (however) doesn't seem to be related to criminal street gangs, but rather a result of frustrated people with no other outlet. When we see graffiti , it's just somebody trying to make a point and get attention. The 'whale' and all the other things we see around campus mean something to somebody, even if that something is nothing. That in itself is a statement. Graffiti often is the product of people with communication problems and who fear to express themselves in another way," Romero said.
A graffiti ARTIST'S RESPONSE:
Dan Tepper, a photography senior, considers himself a graffiti artist. Tepper and a friend opened up an art gallery, 36 Chambers, located downtown, to not only display their artwork - whether it be graffiti, photographs or various other mediums - but also to provide a space for others to show off their skills.
Tepper says, "....(But) despite providing a space to display graffiti legally, some of the essence of graffiti fails to translate to the gallery from the streets. Graffiti is so much more than the final product; it's the preparation. It's the illegal act. It's getting away with it. It's going back and taking pictures of it. ...But, (he laments) ...everything gets painted over all the time, so there's no history.
"One of the problems graffiti faces is people are quick to say, 'it's all either gang activity and it's all vandalism'. You can't do that, you can't say graffiti is something and graffiti isn't something. If you pick up a spray can and put it on a wall it's graffiti, it's art and it's usually illegal. Police and people who have no understanding of graffiti as an art will always be against graffiti because it's everywhere and it's prevalent, but that's what graffiti is about. That's what's cool about graffiti - no matter what, you can't get enough people to paint over it and speak against it. It will still be there no matter what anybody does. It's the good and the bad and the ugly. ..." "
|
The above responses are, it seems, typical - whether you are listening to the opponents & proponents in Austria or Australia. It is the MIDNITE HOUR position that the defacing of public or private property is vandalism, plain and simple, and we note that it is considered a punishable misdemeanor in most localities. Our feelings are that the punishment for such vandalism should fit the crime - and should, for example, be community service - cleaning-off of other illegal graffiti - thereby lessening the community's enormous costs for such cleaning. And it isn't surprising that a very large number of municipalities worldwide are adopting just such community service programs -- a bit like rubbing the dog's nose in it.
However : also in our view - not only is graffiti "art" but it is a legitimate "art form". And those unable to see the possibility that graffiti can be both "illegal" and "art" (that they are in fact mutually exclusive) have our deepest sympathies as to your intellectual shortcomings.
But we won't let our collective feelings on this matter cloud the straight-up reporting. (Good reporting is a mirror, good mirrors have no warp.) And while we don't encourage it, we do report it. If our reportage precipitates a crackdown on these 'art crimes', that's fine and good - we will report that, also. If our reportage elicits interest and enjoyment in the reader, that is also fine and good.
As a matter of general interest, below are three recent publications by authors and publishers who DO think that graffiti is art -
The Art of Rebellion: World of Streetart
by Christian Hundertmark
£12.99 paperback (2005) ISBN 1584232099
Banksy: Wall and Piece
by Banksy
£20.00 hardback (2005) ISBN 1844137864
Stencil Pirates
by Josh MacPhee
£12.99 paperback (2004) ISBN 1932360158
|
- And now to
Bangkok's own brand of Graffiti....
graffiti #078
Electric Superman
8 1/2 ft high x 18 ft
|
graffiti #079
Can Dregs
2 1/2 ft. high x 4 ft.
|
graffiti #080
Guest Book
6 1/2 ft. high x 19 ft.
|
graffiti #081
Little Shock
8 1/2 ft. high x 7 ft.
|
graffiti #082
Mobidick
6 ft. high x 5 ft.
|
graffiti #083
Mural Wars
14 ft. high x 47 ft.
|
graffiti #084
Tix & Tones
7 ft. high x 3 1/2 ft.
|
Graffiti, graffiti , and more Graffiti -
Bangkok's
original and
ONLY graffiti Site
!
|
|
The MIDNITE HOUR Graffiti Page is prepared by Staff Contributor "Boge" Hartman.
(The above photo is not a graffiti per-se, although there are those who have insinuated....)
|
|
Copyright © 2006, BANGKOK EYES /
bangkokeyes.com
|